I came across this article from the Washington Post this morning:
American Teacher in Japan Under Fire for Lessons on Japan's History of Discrimination
It also makes me a little sad to think that if Jane Elliot taught her infamous 'Eye of the Storm' lesson today, she would probably attract an equal amount of negative attention.
We go to school so that we can learn about our universe, planet, environment; our country, city, community and about ourselves. The relationship between all and any of these things is never simple. Nor is it always happy and shiny, in fact often it comprises violence, pollution, corruption and yes, discrimination.
I admired Elliot's courage to turn an already difficult discussion into a hands-on learning activity. Perhaps it was not courage but simple straight forward thinking - good teachers know that people learn best through experience.
I have no doubt that the students felt very uncomfortable, even upset during this lesson. Of course a lesson plan that lists 'upset the students' among it's goals should be considered very carefully! But isn't this sadness and anger the emotional response we would like the entire human race to have when they observe discrimination in the real world? And imagine if, upon experiencing that emotion, students had been taught the skills to intervene, to stand up, to say 'this is not fair'. To make changes.
I support any teacher who helps to create a world like that.
Further Reading:
Not directly related, but more recent.
http://www.good.is/posts/what-if-we-taught-kids-about-skin-color-and-racism-the-way-we-teach-math
Class cancelled because the content was too uncomfortable for students? How far do we let this go?
http://www.takepart.com/article/2013/06/12/seattle-teacher-forced-out-teaching-kids-about-racism